Kebaowek First Nation turns to Supreme Court to rule on UNDRIP, consultation and a nuclear waste dump

Jesse Staniforth
5 Min Read
Kebaowek First Nation turns to Supreme Court to rule on UNDRIP, consultation and a nuclear waste dump

Kebaowek First Nation (KFN) intends to ask the Supreme Court to hear its legal case against Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) according to a release Monday. In October, the Federal Court of Appeal ruled that CNL and the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission were not required to consider the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples when consulting or developing a project for a low-level nuclear waste dump near KFN’s ancestral territory. KFN announced today it is filing a leave to appeal the Federal Court of Appeal’s Oct. 16 decision, and also filing a motion to expedite the application, since construction on the nuclear-waste site could begin as early as next year. “The legal challenge goes far beyond a single nuclear waste project,” KFN’s council argued in the press release. “At its heart is a question of national importance: Does Canada’s commitments in its federal legislation on the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) require federal administrative bodies to consider and apply UNDRIP now in their consultation processes and decisions affecting Indigenous lands and rights?” Kebaowek is located in the far west of Quebec, roughly 400 kilometres north of Oshawa. More than a debate over the nuclear-waste facility, KFN said the Supreme Court must clarify how UNDRIP, incorporated into law through the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, must shape government decisions and Indigenous consultation processes. Kebaowek First Nation Chief Lance Haymond said his Nation’s fight has never been about preventing the nuclear-waste disposal facility alone, but about whether Canada is welling to respect Indigenous rights in action. “When decisions affecting our lands, waters and future generations are made without our free, prior and informed consent, reconciliation remains an empty promise,” Haymond said. “We are turning to the Supreme Court because First Nations across this country deserve clarity, accountability and meaningful respect for their rights.” Haymond was supported by Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Woodhouse Nepinak as well as by Assembly of First Nations Quebec–Labrador Regional Chief Francis Verreault-Paul. “I commend Kebaowek First Nation for this brave decision,” Verreault-Paul said. “Rights cannot exist only on paper. They must shape the decisions governments make when our lands, waters and rights are at stake. That means honouring the duty to consult and giving real effect to the principle of free, prior and informed consent. First Nations should not have to go to court time and again to compel governments to respect rights they have already committed to uphold. Yet the Chalk River case shows that, far too often, this remains our only recourse.” In February 2025, a Federal Court found in favour of KFN’s argument against a plan for a low-level nuclear-waste facility to be located at the Chalk River Nuclear Laboratories campus in Deep River, Ont., located about 180 km west of Ottawa. The Federal Court found that since Parliament had adopted the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples into law, demands on administrative tribunals like the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) to meet the duty to consult and accommodate had increased. The Federal Court ordered CNL and CNSC to carry out further consultation with First Nations prior to moving ahead on the waste facility. Jesse StaniforthOnline Journalist | MontrealJesse joined APTN as a producer after 16 years as a print and web journalist. During seven of those years, he covered the Cree Nation of Eeyou Istchee for community newsmagazine The Nation. Jesse’s writing on Indigenous issues has also appeared in Canadian Geographic, the Toronto Star, the Rover, The Eastern Door, Metro, and the Huffington Post. Continue Reading

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Please Login to Comment.