In an open letter to Prime Minister Mark Carney and Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull Masty, the First Nations Leadership Council (FNLC) is calling for an immediate end to the second-generation cut-off. The FNLC is made up of the B.C. Assembly of First Nations, First Nations Summit and the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs. It’s calling for an end to sex and race-based discrimination in the Indian Act, and removal of the second-generation cutoff. “We fully support the amendments to Bill S-2 made by the Standing Senate Committee on Indigenous Peoples and adopted by the Senate of Canada on December 4, 2025,” the FNLC said in the letter. “Further, we are concerned with the Minister of Indigenous Services Canada’s (ISC) use of a secretive process regarding the new standalone legislation, which violates the legal duty to consult in good faith.” The second-generation cutoff is when a person, under section 6(1) of the Indian Act, passes status to a child no matter who the other parent is. But a person under section 6(2) can pass it on only if the other parent is also registered as “status” under the Indian Act. After two generations of parenting with someone who is not registered, the third generation is out. That is the second-generation cut-off. The FNLC maintains that the immediate elimination of the second-generation cut-off is supported by UN human rights bodies including the UN Human Rights Committee, the UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, and, in May 2026, the UN Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. “For months, Bill S-2 has been stalled in the Standing Committee on Indigenous and Northern Affairs (INAN Committee), while the Minister insisted upon further consultations and then argued for broader registration reform and confused the issues of band membership and self-determination over citizenship with Indian status, and is now proposing new draft legislation. These deceptive tactics are a red herring to distract and delay the passage of Bill S-2,” the letter stated. First Nations Summit Political executive Robert Phillips said in an interview with APTN News that it’s frustrating that “we’ve governed ourselves for thousands of years. And to remove second-generation cutoff and maybe replace it with universal one parent rule, or introducing legislation-and then it’s stalling?” “We’re getting to the point where now we’re in argumentative stage…I do believe we need to be at a table and say that the authority should rest with First Nations and those that have treaties or those that have Aboriginal rights like here in British Columbia…,” Phillips said. According to Phillips, Gull-Masty has invited “select First Nations leaders” to consult with ISC on new draft legislation to address the second-generation cut-off. In the letter to Carney and Gull-Masty, the FNLC said, “we understand that… the minister has invited select First Nations leaders to consult with ISC regarding new draft legislation to address the second-generation cut-off, on the condition that they sign a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA), which binds them to not disclose any information that is shared with them for a period of five years, unless that information is disclosed to the public by the Minister.” That doesn’t sit well with the FNLC. “Using NDAs to convene meetings with selected leaders blocks First Nations leaders from consulting their Nations, members, technical and legal advisors. This secretive and selective process is an alarming escalation of the government’s tactics to undermine the broad support of First Nations.” Read More: Senators vote to end the second-generation cutoff for ‘status Indians’ According to a statement from Gull-Masty’s office, a “collaborative process” on the second-generation cut off and section 10 voting thresholds concluded at the end of July, where the government invited First Nations to “put forward their own proposals and solutions to address these inequities in the Indian Act. “We heard a range of perspectives, proposals, and priorities, alongside a shared sense of urgency: the second generation cut-off must be addressed,” according to a statement provided by Gull-Masty’s office. “While the Collaborative Process has now concluded, the work continues. We are currently reviewing the proposals, feedback and perspectives shared through the process to inform next steps, including legislative reform.” The FNLC said the process goes against “the vast majority of First Nations across Canada” and introducing new standalone legislation ignores “broad support from First Nations and First Nations rights-holders…and directly contravenes the mandate of the vast majority of First Nations across Canada, who are on record supporting the immediate passage of Bill S-2 as amended by the Senate.” Leanne SandersOnline Journalist | Western CanadaLeanne has a certificate in broadcasting and has more than 12 years of radio news experience, both as an anchor and reporter in Saskatchewan and Alberta. The Métis journalist is a passionate writer and born storyteller and loves to connect with people and learn about their life experiences. Continue Reading
First Nations Leadership Council sends open letter to the prime minister, Indigenous Services over delay in passing Bill S-2
Leave a Comment



